Group of Eight leaders pledged to
make cheaper drugs to combat diseases such as HIV/AIDS more easily available in
developing nations.
In a "health action plan" released during their summit in the
French spa town of Evian, the industrialised nations' club pledged to boost the
distribution of cheap medicines in a "fair, efficient and sustainable"
way.
Welcoming drugs companies' efforts to make discounted drugs more available,
the G8 leaders said they would "strongly support" further efforts,
although the paper contained little in the way of specific policies.
Additionally, the statement backed a moratorium on challenging countries
under World Trade Organisation rules over the production of generic versions of
patented drugs.
Pharmaceutical multinationals have long been criticised by health activists
for the prices they charge for HIV/AIDS drugs and for their efforts to prevent
generic copies of the medicines being made.
Last month Britain's GlaxoSmithKline, the world's leading supplier of
HIV/AIDS drugs, which has faced particular criticism, slashed the price of its
top anti-retroviral treatment for the world's poorest countries by almost half.
BEIJING
(AFP) - A family in central China's Anhui province has been awarded 45,000 yuan
(5,430 US dollars) in compensation from a local hospital after their relative
died after contracting AIDS during a routine surgical procedure, state press
said.
The Anhui high court ordered the Fuyang Number Two People's Hospital to pay
compensation to the family of Xia Zhenrong last week, Xinhua news agency
reported Tuesday on its website.
Xia contracted HIV, the virus that causes AIDS, after a blood transfusion
during a back operation in May 1995, the report said.
She launched her lawsuit against the hospital upon discovery in March 2002
that she had Acquired Immuno Deficiency Syndrome, for which there is no known
cure. She died on May 20 of that same year.
"This is not the first case that a person contracting AIDS in a surgical
procedure has sued and won in China," said Hu Jia, a director of AIDS
Action Project, one of China's only non-government AIDS awareness groups.
"The award is way too low and is not enough to compensate the duress
patients go through when finding out they have got AIDS, or the medical expenses
already paid," he said.
Very few of these types of cases reach compensation level, he said, as the
government usually chooses to hush up the cases by settling out of court.
There are roughly one million HIV-positive people in China, a figure that
could increase ten-fold by the end of the decade, top government and
international health officials have warned.
Hundreds of thousands of people were infected during a government-sanctioned,
appallingly unsanitary blood-collection program in central Henan and other
provinces in the 1980s and 1990s.
By Russell Flannery
Health care in China in many ways hasn't changed much since New York-born
Roberta Lipson got there in 1979 to sell medical equipment for a small Boston
company. She'd gone through college with an interest in the ancient culture of a
country just then opening to the modern world. She remains in the field that
gained her entrée, but with an eye very much to the future, not the past.
Medicine in her chosen land ought to be ripe for the new. The health system
is still state-dominated and, as the panic surrounding the SARS epidemic has
made clear, the level of care in most of the country lags behind that of much of
the world. About three-quarters of its citizens have no insurance coverage, and
China--forget SARS--boasts some of the world's worst problems with tuberculosis,
hepatitis and, it is suspected, HIV .
Much has improved in the past two decades. Growing income in China's booming
economy and rising educational standards have raised demand for common checkups,
cosmetic surgery and dental and eye care among a new middle class of about 400
million.
SARS, if nothing else, illustrates that the government doesn't have the
budget or personnel to provide for all of China's health needs. In the future
private companies--domestic and foreign--will take a bigger part in everything
from hospital services to drug distribution to health insurance. "We
welcome a greater role for companies that can offset some of the relative
weakness of the existing system," says Peter Zhang, a district health chief
in Shanghai.
Lipson anticipated that early on, co-founding in 1981 with fellow American
entrepreneur Elyse Silverberg their now-Nasdaq-listed company, Chindex
International. At $71 million in sales last year, it provides lessons in how to
work through China's "system"--a morass of rigid state-run hospitals,
murky investment rules and a protectionist distribution web. Chindex sells to
2,000 of the biggest buyers of imported medical products and equipment in the
country.
Chindex, for instance, is a key sales rep in China for Siemens medical
equipment and distributor of skin-care lines for L'Oréal. Even as SARS was
peaking in April, Chindex was rolling out Natural Formula creams, shampoos and
deodorants made by Nesh Cosmetics of Israel. Later this year it plans to
introduce a line of feminine products from U.S.-based C.B. Fleet.
But Lipson does more than equip and stock emergency rooms and medicine
chests. Chindex started the nation's first private for-profit hospital in
Beijing in 1997. It plans to open its second in Shanghai in the second half of
this year.
The stakes in China's health care are big not only for industry entrants like
Lipson's. If China can't convince foreigners that it has an adequate health
system, the country's status as the world's No. 1 recipient of foreign direct
investment ($53 billion last year) will be in jeopardy in the future. And
successful reforms could also go a long way toward solving a key Chinese
macroeconomic problem--what to do about its high savings rate, now at about 40%.
That money, worth about $1 trillion, could drive economic growth if channeled
into health insurance or directly into physician fees. Today most is on deposit
at insolvent government banks that channel it to other hapless government
companies.
Hope for change in health care is high because of fallout from SARS. Wu Yi, a
feisty, no-nonsense protégé of retired Chinese economic czar Zhu Rongji, now
leads China's health ministry. A former trade negotiator, Wu was named to the
job in April, after the authorities in effect admitted to a botched coverup of
the epidemic. Besides her solid reputation in government and pledges to spend
more money ($350 million for poor areas this year), Wu is seen as important
because she was also made vice premier and her clout will raise the political
importance of the health ministry. She could lead the biggest overhaul of
China's health care system in half a century.
The system needs it. Although China has opened up much of its economy in the
last two decades, the vast majority of its 70,000 hospitals and clinics are
government-run. Artificially low prices for medical visits encourage
overprescription of drugs that are sold at in-house pharmacies. There are about
10,000 drug distributors, compared to about 100 significant ones in the U.S.,
according to research firms. "There's going to have to be a lot of
consolidation and efficiency improvements in the whole industry," says
Robert Pollard, general manager in China for London-based Isis Research, a
health care market research company.
Lipson, 48, Chindex's CEO and holder of 13% of its shares, succeeds even in
this environment with solicitousness toward her best accounts. The sole
distributor of Siemens color-ultrasound products in China for more than a dozen
years, Chindex impresses the German giant with an annual "users'
event" attracting 600 clinicians from around the vast country. "They
are very close to the customers, and you have to have been entrepreneurial in
arranging financing and providing service all of this time to achieve
that," says Steven Feinberg, head of Siemens' "medical solutions"
division in China.
Customer knowledge helps with a chronic problem for nearly all businesses in
China: collecting bills. A key to Lipson's staying power over the years has been
her ability to roll with the bureaucracy in Chinese health care.
Chindex, whose Washington, D.C.-area base is a legacy of its origins in
channeling American exports, today has a scant market capitalization of $11
million, even after its stock has doubled in the last six months. Few U.S.
analysts follow the China-focused company, and profits have been choppy, despite
sales that are clearly on an uptrend.
Chindex this year is expanding the number of products it sells to China's
pharmacies. That's not easy right now because China largely doesn't allow
foreign distributors to sell drugs through that channel. Hospitals that have
been getting as much as 70% of their revenue from drugs don't like the gradually
easing restrictions, but are being forced by Beijing to generate cash elsewhere.
Until drug sales are more readily allowed, Lipson will continue to use
proxies: consumer goods such as skin-care items whose relatively high profit
margins look good to druggists. "We need to bring more people into stores,
and this is a good way," says Zhang Peijing, manager of a drugstore on
Shanghai's swank Nanjing Road. The first floor of her store alone has displays
of Natural Formula and L'Oréal items. Nearby lies a display case of ginger root
and other traditional Chinese medicines.
By getting close to the pharmacies now, "we'll be right there" when
WTO reforms kick in, says Lipson. Right now in Shanghai a common painkiller made
in China by Roche sells for 10 cents a pill. Lipson wants to be a supplier of
Western brands for that kind of relief, in addition to creams and gels. Sales of
both potent prescription drugs and over-the-counter remedies are likely to grow
as China overhauls its health reimbursement system in the coming years.
And then there's the ultimate vertical integration, hospital operations. From
selling equipment, Lipson figured out early on that for customers seeking
quality, the facilities themselves are largely a mess. In contrast, her Beijing
United Family Hospital has big bay windows, color TV and modern equipment.
Companies with affiliated health plans include Motorola and ConocoPhillips.
Unlike what you see at local hospitals, patients don't wander around
unaccompanied, rooms are cleaner, and sessions with doctors are longer and more
private. "It's like getting treatment in the West," says Christian
Murck, chairman of the American Chamber of Commerce in Beijing and managing
director of the U.S.-based public relations firm APCO Worldwide. He knows
firsthand because he's been a patient.
To get the hospital license, Lipson forged a joint venture with a minority
investor, the Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences. Revenue last year climbed by
48% to $12 million. "We will prove our model successful," Lipson says.
The hope is that success in Shanghai will pave the way for investment with a
partner that will create a full chain. What about buying state-owned hospitals?
Lipson says no thanks.
Other medical-service companies are looking at China. UK-based BUPA Health
Care Asia has a local partner and an investment from JPChase to gain 70% stakes
in eye-surgery centers in the eastern Chinese cities of Hangzhou and Nanjing.
Medical insurance? Cigna hopes to get a license for a joint venture with the
China Merchants Group by the end of the year. But in that sphere, beware of
false claims, says Stephen Harner, a Shanghai-based financial industry
consultant. This is anything-goes China, after all. "Premiums are high
because the insurers don't want to lose their shirts," Harner says.
By KIM CURTIS, Associated Press Writer
SAN FRANCISCO - Several hemophiliacs filed a lawsuit against Bayer Corp. and
other companies, claiming they exposed patients to HIV and hepatitis C by
selling medicine made with blood from sick, high-risk donors.
The lawsuit alleges the companies continued distributing the blood-clotting
product in Asia and Latin America in 1984 and 1985, even after they stopped
selling it in the United States because of the known risk of HIV and hepatitis
transmission.
The lawsuit filed Monday in federal court seeks class-action status on behalf
of thousands of foreign hemophiliacs who received the product, said attorney
Robert Nelson. It accuses the companies of negligence and fraudulent
concealment.
"This is a worldwide tragedy," Nelson said. "Thousands of
hemophiliacs have unnecessarily died from AIDS and many thousands more are
infected with HIV or hepatitis C."
Bayer rejected the claims, saying in a statement from its headquarters in
Leverkusen, Germany Tuesday that it would examine the lawsuit and prepare its
defense.
"Bayer at all times complied with all regulations in force in the
relevant countries based on the amount of scientific evidence available at the
time," the company said, adding that decisions made 20 years ago should not
be judged by today's scientific knowledge.
Nelson said the lawsuit was filed in California because defendant Cutter
Biological, now a division of Bayer, was formerly based in Berkeley. Several
plasma donation sites also were located in the San Francisco Bay area, he said.
The lawsuit was filed less than two weeks after an investigation by The New
York Times accused the company of selling old stock of the medicine abroad,
while marketing a newer, safer product in the United States.
Bayer told Times it sold the old medicine because some customers doubted the
effectiveness of a new version of the product, and because some countries were
slow to approve its sale.
While the company said it acted responsibly and in line with the best medical
knowledge at the time, Bayer and three other companies that made the concentrate
settled 15 years of U.S. lawsuits from people who took the drug, paying about
$600 million.
The medicine, called Factor VIII concentrate, can stop or prevent potentially
fatal bleeding in people with hemophilia.
Early in the AIDS epidemic, the medicine was commonly made using mingled
plasma from 10,000 or more donors. Because there was not yet a screening test
for HIV, the virus that causes AIDS, thousands of hemophiliacs were infected.
But the lawsuit alleges Bayer and the others refused to take precautions that
could have made the product safer.
As of 1992, the contaminated blood products had infected at least 5,000
hemophiliacs in Europe with HIV. More than 2,000 had already developed AIDS and
1,250 had died from the disease, the lawsuit said.
By the mid-1990s in Japan, hemophiliacs accounted for the majority of the
country's 4,000 reported cases of HIV infection and virtually all infections of
Japan's hemophiliacs have been linked to contaminated blood products imported
from the United States, the lawsuit said.
In Latin America, at least 700 HIV cases are linked to use of contaminated
blood products by hemophiliacs, the lawsuit said.
Steve Sternberg USA TODAY
WASHINGTON -- Health and Human Services Secretary Tommy Thompson said Tuesday
that the United States has stepped up pressure on other countries to follow the
nation's example and boost funding for global AIDS programs.
AIDS advocates, however, say the United States should do even more, criticism
Thompson brushed aside.
''We are active players, we are going to continue to be active players, and
we want other members of the world community also to shoulder the burden,''
Thompson told reporters on the eve of his first board meeting as chairman of the
Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria.
He said the European Commission has finally made good on last year's pledge
to supply the fund with 60 million euros (roughly $70.5 million) and has agreed
to add another 375 million euros (roughly $440.8 million) over the next five
years. ''Hopefully, they will increase it again,'' he said.
More than two decades into the AIDS epidemic, the disease is still spreading.
Roughly 40 million people are infected with HIV worldwide, and 14,000 people
becoming infected each day.
Although AIDS advocates praise President Bush's five-year, $15 billion AIDS
initiative, they note that Bush asked Congress to supply just $1.7 billion of
the $3 billion he had pledged next year for government-sponsored AIDS in his
State of the Union address.
Most of the $1.7 billion will be used to treat up to 3 million people with
anti-HIV drugs, 10 million with other types of drugs and prevent 7 million new
infections.
The United States also will contribute $350 million of the total to the
United Nations' Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria. U.N.
Secretary-General Kofi Annan has asked the United States to supply $3.5 billion
a year to the fund, which was set up three years ago by the United Nations and
the G8 group of industrialized nations.
Congress has authorized up to $1 billion for the fund, but only on condition
that the total amount not exceed one-third of the total given by other
countries. ''We're above that,'' Thompson said, noting that the United States
has contributed nearly half of the amount now in the fund.
But AIDS advocates say the money falls far short of an estimated $5 billion
the fund will need next year to begin to make a difference.
''We're letting millions of people die and millions of children be orphaned
for lack of funding,'' says Jeffrey Sachs, a leading Columbia University
economist and AIDS expert. ''The global fund is facing a desperate shortage of
money.''
''Pledges by a number of countries have not been funded,'' says Nils
D'Daulaire, president of the Global Health Council. ''A pledge doesn't have a
lot of value unless there's money to back it.''
Thompson says that fund's board of directors will take up the shortage when
they meet Thursday. He also plans to invite corporate executives to accompany
him to Africa as part of his fundraising drive. ''If I can get people to Africa,
visit these orphanages and get them to pick up and hold some of these orphans,
that's the best way to tell the story.''
Thompson also said Tuesday that he probably would not stay on as health
secretary if Bush is re-elected and will pursue opportunities in the private
sector.
MANILA (AFP) - Without constant monitoring, the Philippines could be within a
few years or a few thousand cases from the threshold of a devastating AIDS
epidemic, despite currently low infection rates, experts warned.
A large, jetsetting labor force, a national aversion to condoms and
irresponsible sexual behavior are crucial precursors to an epidemic explosion,
UN and government officials told Thursday a ceremony to mark a new AIDS
prevention partnership with the government, the UN's AIDS program and two
foreign companies based here.
The Philippines has confounded experts with its low prevalence of the Human
Immunodeficiency Virus, which causes AIDS. Fewer than 2,000 cases have been
reported in 19 years, with 253 deaths.
"The Philippines may be lucky to have a number of factors that have kept
the HIV prevalence low to date. But luck is not the way to control the
epidemic," warned Zahidul Huque, an official of the United Nations
Population Fund.
Common to most areas that have suffered the brunt of an AIDS epidemic -- such
as South Africa, with the highest proportion of HIV-positive people in the world
-- is an exponential increase in the number of reported cases in a short span of
time.
"We should seize the window of opportunity now, while we can still do
something about it," said Consorcia Quizon, head of the health department's
epidemiology center, who placed the department's annual budget for AIDS
prevention at 20 million pesos (376,000 dollars).
"Maybe we haven't had the critical mass of infected people from whom
other people are going to be infected," she said.
"We cannot say that that will be the same situation next year, or in the
next five years."
She told AFP actual HIV infections in the Philippines could be closer to
6,000, while Huque said it could be "somewhere between 7,000 and
9,000."
"If you double it, like you get 20,000, that would be a critical mass I
would say" and would unleash a nationwide epidemic, Huque told AFP.
If Acquired Immuno Deficiency Syndrome hit five percent of the Philippines'
80 million people, national economic output could be devastated -- assuming the
productive segments of society were affected, he said.
Nearly 10 percent of Filipinos work overseas, including several hundred
thousand seafarers considered high risk for AIDS infection.
Rates of infection in commercial sex workers and intravenous drug users have
been "consistently less than one percent," said Quizon. But while
surveys show there is a high degree of AIDS awareness in these high-risk
populations, it has "not translated into a change in behavior."
While sex is the main mode of HIV transmission in the Philippines, a national
survey conducted by a Manila university last year showed 70 percent of men aged
14 to 45 did not use condoms.
The largely-Roman Catholic Philippines follows the lead of the church, which
considers the use of contraceptives to be encouraging of promiscuous sexual
behavior.
Huque warned that without continued attention to HIV/AIDS and funding of
awareness and treatment campaigns, the Philippines is at risk for a higher
infection rate, and urged Manila to do more to take its fight against AIDS to
"every corner of the country."
The two companies, Amkor-Anam and Shell Philippines Exploration, have agreed
to contribute funds and resources to promote AIDS awareness in their workplaces.
JOHANNESBURG (Reuters) - South Africa's top tourism trade group has launched
a new "AIDS insurance" policy to provide potentially life-saving drugs
to travellers who might become infected while on holiday.
South Africa has the world's single highest AIDS caseload with some five
million people infected with the HIV virus .
Gail McCann, chief executive officer of the Southern Africa Tourism Services
Association (SATSA), said on Friday the policy was being offered to group
members who want to both protect their clients and prolong the lives of HIV
-infected staff.
"People coming to South Africa are a little nervous from an AIDS
perspective. This might help," McCann said.
The insurance will pay for and deliver anti-retroviral drugs so treatment can
begin with a 72-hour window which doctors say may prevent infection from taking
hold.
South Africa currently does not provide anti-retroviral drugs in public
sector hospitals, a policy government critics say is causing the AIDS deaths of
some 600 people every day.
"If you get to a game lodge and you have a risk exposure they would be
aware of who to contact," said Charles Parsons, chief executive officer of
Calibre Clinical Consultants, the AIDS services company handling the insurance
policy.
While SATSA -- which represents more than 800 tourism-related companies
including such giants as South African Airways -- hopes the "AIDS
insurance" may calm nervous travellers, they say one of the key aims of the
programme is to give tourism company employees greater access to HIV treatment.
McCann said the health insurance policy would be extended to company
employees at a cost of as little as 3.50 rand (26 pence) per month.
"It won't save their lives but it will prolong their lives," McCann
said. "AIDS is a reality in South Africa...a lot of money is being spent
and being lost on retraining our staff because they are dying from AIDS."
GENEVA (AFP) - The Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria
appealed to donors to help provide three billion dollars (2.5 billion euros) by
the end of next year to finance prevention and treatment programmes.
"On the occasion of its Fifth Board Meeting, the Global Fund implored
public and private donors to contribute three billion US dollars by the end of
2004 in order to fully finance anticipated country proposals to prevent and
treat AIDS, TB and malaria," a fund statement said after the meeting here.
It said the Fund's Executive Director Richard Feachem had acknowledged the
combined leadership of the United States and France in resource mobilization. In
authorizing up to one billion dollars for its 2004 fiscal year, US President
George W. Bush and Congress had challenged other donors to respond, and they had
responded, the statement said.
France's President Jacques Chirac had led an effort for Europe to raise one
billion dollars and had called on public and private donors outside the United
States and Europe to also raise one billion dollars.
"The Global Fund also praised the outcome of the recent Evian Summit,
where G8 and African Heads of State, as well as the United Nations Secretary
General, reaffirmed their support for the Global Fund," it said.
The purpose of the Fund is to attract, manage and disburse additional
resources through a new public-private partnership that will make a sustainable
and significant contribution to the reduction of infections, illness and death,
thereby mitigating the impact of HIV/AIDS, tuberculosis and malaria in countries
in need, and contributing to poverty reduction.
[Home]
[Previous
news]